LovelyHomes journal /

Laws, Regulations & Policies

Wrongful Caveats: Removal, Compensation and Proof of Loss

Singapore River at Robertson Quay - 2022-08-14
Singapore River at Robertson Quay - 2022-08-14 (photographed 2022). Photo: Wzhkevin. Source (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Singapore_River_at_Robertson_Quay_-_2022-08-14.jpg) · CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0).

Removing a disputed caveat and recovering money for it are separate questions. A seller who gets a caveat removed should not assume that every delay bill will be paid by the caveator. The compensation claim needs the relevant wrongful conduct, financial loss and a connection between them.

What section 128 covers

Section 128(1) of the Land Titles Act 1993 addresses wrongful, vexatious or unreasonable lodgment, procuring a caveat’s lapse, and a caveator’s refusal or failure to withdraw after a request. Liability concerns pecuniary loss attributable to the relevant conduct. Subsection (2) provides for recovery through court proceedings.

The section is not limited to a registered owner complaining about the original lodgment. Subsection (3) restricts a caveator’s own claim concerning a procured lapse where the caveator had an opportunity but failed to take all reasonable preventive steps. The parties, the particular act and the route of claim therefore matter.

Under subsection (4), a caveator who does not withdraw within seven days of the termination of the claimed interest is deemed to let the caveat remain without reasonable cause. That is a specific rule about the end of the claimed right. It is not a general seven-day grace period following any objection, nor does it establish the amount of compensation.

A removal order did not produce compensation in Kok Zhen Yen

In Kok Zhen Yen and another v Beth Candice Wu [2023] SGHC 126, the General Division of the High Court issued grounds on 4 May 2023. The caveat was removed, but compensation was refused. Paragraphs 41 to 46 distinguish the wrongful conduct from the missing evidence of accrued financial loss. The court did not treat distress or speculative future losses as sufficient proof of the damages sought.

The practical lesson is to prepare the money claim separately from the request to clear the title. An invoice alone does not explain why the caveat caused that expense. A proposed cost that never arose is different from an actual payment or liability.

Build a loss record that explains the connection

For each claimed expense, record what happened, the date, the amount and the document supporting it. Then explain what would have happened without the disputed caveat. Keep the sale contract, the original completion arrangements and the correspondence about why a dealing could not proceed together.

For temporary accommodation, keep the booking, payment and the reason the stay was needed. For an asserted financing cost, separate the ordinary loan cost from the additional amount said to result from the delay. For a lost sale, preserve the buyer’s actual communications and the transaction documents rather than substitute an estate agent’s estimate of a hoped-for price.

These are evidence prompts, not a list of automatically recoverable items. Whether a sum qualifies, whether it was caused by the relevant conduct, and whether other issues defeat the claim require advice on the actual facts. Separate money already spent, liabilities already incurred and estimates of future expenditure.

A simple schedule exposes weak assumptions

Illustration only: a household lists S$2,400 paid for a temporary stay, S$600 paid for storage and S$10,000 of hoped-for rent. The first two amounts total S$3,000, but their recoverability still needs proof of the relevant cause and legal requirements. The S$10,000 should remain separately identified as an estimate unless the evidence establishes an actual loss. Adding all three and calling S$13,000 a compensation entitlement would be misleading.

Also record any reimbursement, refund or avoided expense. Do not count the same bill under both accommodation and moving costs. Keep legal-cost orders distinct from the compensation schedule for advice on the correct treatment.

Protect the transaction while the claim is assessed

Buyers need a workable completion mechanism; sellers need a realistic account of what can be resolved and when. Do not promise that a compensation claim will fund the next home, or change contractual dates through an informal understanding. Our conveyancing guide covers the wider completion process, while the funding calendar helps separate money available now from receipts expected later.

The case example addresses the compensation issue at the stated paragraphs. A complete appeal history has not been established, so ask LovelyHomes for an introduction to a property lawyer to check current treatment and advise on the documents before relying on it in a dispute. Bring the caveat, underlying agreement, notices, sale documents and loss schedule together.

Photograph: Singapore River at Robertson Quay, 14 August 2022, Wzhkevin, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source: commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Singapore_River_at_Robertson_Quay_-_2022-08-14.jpg. Licence: creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/. Resized and displayed cropped. Neighbourhood context, not a home assessed in this article.

Need a brochure, price list or professional introduction?

Contact Lin Xuan at 82222556 or Ade at 81888871 or Benn at 83218774 for the full project brochure, latest available price list, a viewing, or introductions to bankers who can help you compare home-loan rates and packages to find the best available option for your needs. If you need legal advice on a property purchase, sale or tenancy, we can also put you in touch with property lawyers.

WhatsApp Lin Xuan | WhatsApp Ade. Let us know the project or property question you would like help with. Prices and availability are subject to developer confirmation, while loan terms and approval are determined by the bank.

Lin Xuan: ONG LIN XUAN, CEA registration R069812H. Ade: CHUA MUAY MUAY (ADE CHUA), CEA registration R014252F. ERA REALTY NETWORK PTE LTD, estate agent licence L3002382K.

Benn: TAN JUN FENG, BENNEDICT (BENNEDICT TAN), CEA registration R058941E. PROPNEX REALTY PTE. LTD., estate agent licence L3008022J.

Translate »